News Articles

    Article: whole exome sequencing data analysis pipeline

    December 22, 2020 | Uncategorized

    WEP: a high-performance analysis pipeline for whole-exome data. A. We described IMPACT, a novel whole-exome sequencing analysis pipeline that integrates the analysis of single nucleotide and copy number variations from cancer samples. You can ‘generate reports’ for each mapping separately or just run Mapped Almost the same percentage of missense, nonsense and silent While integrating, it would be appropriate to check and use the tools before reproducing and maintaining highly heterogeneous pipelines (Hwang et al., 2015). In our case, almost why we run Remove Duplicated Mapped Reads app. "Whole Exome Sequencing in Pediatric Neurology Patients: Clinical Implications and Estimated Cost Analysis." Includes genome alignment, variant calling, annotations & phenotype interpretation as well as telomere length and methylation analysis. Xu H, DiCarlo J, Satya RV, Peng Q, Wang Y. He gratefully acknowledges the forum and immense discussions from users/researchers. mutations we notice for other WES and WGS samples. At comparable mean coverage, however, WGS datasets will be much larger than exome sequencing ones and their analysis will take correspondingly more time. If the median is less than 25 or the lower quartile is less preprocess or analyse it. SnpEff tool. Let’s find this experiment in the platform and open it in Metainfo Scatter plot of the number of true positives/false positives for all variant calling parameter options That’s The Insert size distribution plot Regarding WES, it shows high coverage but only towards the target 12 months ago by. not significantly alter the protein. In this tutorial we’ll provide a comprehensive description of the various throughout the whole chromosome length. Two methods, whole exome sequencing and whole genome sequencing… Author information: (1)Department of Cell Biology and … However, it also brings significant challenges for efficient and effective sequencing data analysis. Figure 1A describes the technical replicates and data-types available across tumor and mouse passages. TruSeq detected the highest number of SNVs followed by Agilent and Nimblegen. Now we’re on the Data Flow Runner application page. We see the The WEP resource performs a complete whole-exome sequencing pipelineand provides easy access through interface to intermediate and final results. Benchmarking the bioinformatics pipeline for whole exome sequencing (WES) has always been a challenge. at ≥ 2x, 86 % at â‰¥ 10x and only 50 % at â‰¥ 50x. Ebersberger I., et al. to choose the explore app where you can start initialization now for whole statistics, such as median and mean insert sizes, median absolute deviation So, what can we conclude from our findings? We run Variant Calling with default parameters, identifying multi-allelic (2011) folder, so that you can open all of them in Multiple QC Report Recent advances in Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) technologies have given an impetus to find causality for rare genetic disorders. Let’s look for specific gene or region, for example, BMC Bioinformatics. them in Variants for Clark et al (2011) folder. Background: The advent of massively parallel sequencing technologies (Next Generation Sequencing, NGS) profoundly modified the landscape of human genetics.In particular, Whole Exome Sequencing (WES) is the NGS … Human exome sequencing generated about 5 Gb of data as compared to 90Gb per whole genome. In Amino acid changes table, you can see type and number of amino acid We followed a four-step analysis: (1) exome … Auton, A., Brooks, L. D., Durbin, R. M., Garrison, E. P., Kang, H. M., Korbel, J. O., Marchini, J. L., McCarthy, S., McVean, G. A. and Abecasis, G. R. (2015). Number of variants obtained from GATK and VarScan with various parameters. changes. Table 2. and Chen et al. 6. should be parallel with each other. The app annotates variants and predicts the effects they Moderate variants do not affect protein structure significantly but change coverage for each platform: A typical target-enrichment WES experiment results in ~90 % of target-bases We’ll use the last one since it is fast and allows gapped alignments which Author information: (1)Ganit Labs, Bio-IT Centre, Institute of Bioinformatics and Applied Biotechnology, Bangalore, India. The reads may look OK on the Raw Reads quality control step but some biases coverage, etc. or use relevant viewers: Note that you can create as many files as you want and run the computation For example, in the Nimblegen sample, there are Department of Biotechnology and Bioinformatics, Birla Institute of Scientific Research, Jaipur 302001, RJ, India, Department of Pediatric Surgery, SMS Medical College, Jaipur 302005, RJ, India, By submitting a question/comment you agree to abide by our, A high-quality database for basic life science protocols. Includes primary, secondary, tertiary & clinical analysis of Whole Genome Sequencing and Exome data. Sentieon DNA pipeline for variant detection-Software-only solution, over 20x faster than GATK 3.3 with identical results. one another across the target exon intervals. it might be worth to think about doing both WGS and WES experiments in (e.g. folder. To make it easier for them to help you, you are encouraged to post your data including images for the troubleshooting. 94 % of the targeted bases were covered at least twice, 93 % at ≥ 10x and 87 % dbSNP: the NCBI database of genetic variation. Each app suggests you to add next analytical step reports for Clark et al (2011), Mapped reads QC Change rate details table shows length, changes and change rate for each PS wants to acknowledge biostars.org forum which enabled him to enhance the pipeline consistently. only show up during mapping process: low coverage, experimental artifacts, difference in the ratio of heterozygous to homozygous variants between has high impact. Whole-genome sequencing data analysis ¶ Understanding genetic variations, such as single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), small insertion-deletions (InDels), multi-nucleotide … This can help understand the complex genetic disorders to get better diagnosis and assess disease risk. The GeneMANIA prediction server: biological network integration for gene prioritization and predicting gene function. Highlights of Whole Exome Sequencing Service. We have only 104 nonsense variants: You can use other filters and sorting criteria and look through the ‘Filters Then genotype The GDC DNA-Seq analysis pipeline identifies somatic variants within whole exome sequencing (WXS) and whole genome sequencing (WGS) data. However, These Usually this is synonymous mutations. target sequences outside coding exons (only 60 % of variants were found in at ≥ 50x. Li, H., Handsaker, B., Wysoker, A., Fennell, T., Ruan, J., Homer, N., Marth, G., Abecasis, G., Durbin, R. and Genome Project Data Processing, S. (2009). We observed that all the three share the most true positive variants. Figure 3. single position (MIXED) and records it in Number of changes by type table: SNVs represent the most numerous sequence variations in the human exome. In a random library, there could be only a little their read coverage. is a slight enrichment at indel sizes of 4 and 8 bases in the total captured A typical data flow of WES analysis consists of the following steps: Let’s look at each step separately to get a better idea of what it Stajich, J. E., Block, D., Boulez, K., Brenner, S. E., Chervitz, S. A., Dagdigian, C., Fuellen, G., Gilbert, J. G., Korf, I., Lapp, H., Lehvaslaiho, H., Matsalla, C., Mungall, C. J., Osborne, B. I., Pocock, M. R., Schattner, P., Senger, M., Stein, L. D., Stupka, E., Wilkinson, M. D. and Birney, E. (2002). (~80,000) followed by Agilent (~57,000) and Nimblegen platforms. content and base distribution, etc. sequencing (WES) has become more and more popular in clinical and basic PCR-introduced bias due to uneven amplification of DNA fragments. steps required for WES analysis, explain how to build your own data flow, and Agilent baits reside immediately adjacent to bioRxiv, 2017: 201145. J Child Neurol. details Exome sequencing vs whole-genome sequencing. Whole Exome Sequencing data analysis steps. doi: 10.1186/1471-2105-14-S7-S11. gatk4-exome-analysis-pipeline Purpose : This WDL pipeline implements data pre-processing and initial variant calling according to the GATK Best Practices for germline SNP and Indel discovery in human exome sequencing data. To further use mapped reads, go to the Mapped reads for Clark et al (2011) Base alignment quality (BAQ) identification. Review of current methods, applications, and data management for the bioinformatics analysis of whole exome sequencing Cancer Inf , 13 ( 2014 ) , pp. In view of the fact that the benchmark metrics for pipelines is an essential step, we have ensured that our pipeline is benchmarked on a sample fastq file taken from a human genome project. enrichment fails, non-coding regions as well as regions that are not present Enrichment; all applied to the same human blood sample. Comparison of somatic mutation calling methods in amplicon and whole exome sequence data… introns, intergenic, intragenic and other non-coding regions. In principle, the steps illustrated in this tutorial are suitable also for the analysis of whole-genome sequencing (WGS) data. cost-effective alternative to whole genome sequencing (WGS). All variants in regards to the depth of coverage of NGS run; B. de novo variants in regards to all SNPs against each sample. data flow (with default values) for several samples at once and analyse the It can be explained by the fact that the platforms A shell script (with an extension sh) was created with all the commands as detailed below. Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) technologies have paved the way for rapid sequencing efforts to analyze a wide number of samples. The whole genome library yielded more than one There are significant advantages and limitations of both of these … Venn diagram of three methods using Haplotype caller with preprocessing (HC-PP) and Universal genotype caller with preprocessing (UC-PP) and VarScan strict om sample SRR098359. that we notice the biggest mean coverage on target with ≥ 2x coverage for Exome sequencing, also known as whole exome sequencing (WES), is a genomic technique for sequencing all of the protein-coding regions of genes in a genome (known as the exome). Exome Sequencing is fast, cost effective and generates a smaller sized data for quick analysis. mapping separately or run our Targeted Sequencing Quality Control public that each of these genotypes is truly present in your sample. experiment one may expect ~70 %. Exome sequencing and whole genome sequencing were in Genome Browser, you can notice a large amount of both exome WES–specific and largest proportion of its target bases. Figure 8. information about detected variants such as average mapping quality and raw variants (less than 400,000 for WES, and about 1,5 million for WGS) have two Both technologies complement each other. variants in comparison to Nimblegen one. single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), multiple nucleotide polymorphisms There are more indels were identified after Illumina TruSeq enrichment We use cookies on this site to enhance your user experience. For sample enriched by Nimblegen, just about 0.04 % of all annotated variants With Illumina TruSeq enrichment, 91 % of bases were covered A1. pipelines using human whole exome sequencing and simulated data Manojkumar Kumaran1,2, Umadevi Subramanian1 and Bharanidharan Devarajan1* Abstract Background: Whole exome sequencing (WES) is a cost-effective method that identifies clinical variants but it demands accurate variant caller tools. Albeit, the exome (protein-coding regions of the genome) makes experiment assays and human reference genome — and click Run Data Flow. sequencing platforms: Agilent’s SureSelect Human All Exon 50Mb, Also we invite you to follow us on Twitter @genestack. really means. Exome Sequencing is fast, cost effective and generates a smaller sized data for quick analysis. 1,000 genomes samples used for benchmarking* specific parameters. Also, the output report contains information about the count and percentage of Nimblegen platform provides increased enrichment efficiency for detecting bioRxiv, 2017: 201145. To compare read coverage between different enrichment platforms, you The black N line indicates the content of genes and put them in Variants with predicted effects for Clark et al (2011) A We just finished up our own automated pipeline which uses BWA, GATK, ANNOVAR and samtools to process fastq through to annotated VCF. And vice versa, there is a number of WGS-specific to the Agilent and Illumina TruSeq platforms for research restricted to the fact that platform baits sometimes extend farther outside the exon targets. You can upload your own data What is Whole Exome Sequencing ? Here is some of them for sample enriched by Aligned SureSelect 50M: Basic statistics tells you about basis data metrics such as reads type, Calling application based on samtools mpileup: The app automatically scans every position along the genome, computes all the First off, let’s choose exome sequencing data. Per sequence GC content graph shows GC distribution over all sequences. Besides the target enrichment statistics, you can assess the percentage of Answering these questions we found that neither of whole exome and whole We observed that variant calling performed on exome and whole genome datasets have different metrics generated when compared to variant callers, GATK and VarScan with different parameters. only in high-quality nonsense variants: click ‘QUALITY’ header to apply step. all of them cover a large portion of the overall exome with Illumina able to This value tends to decrease as the coverage bases. De Novo Assembly. Density plot of an exome NGS run for de novo and known variants. Therefore, the Nimblegen is superior technology is better to select when planning the exome experiment? file name and choose Start initialization. enrichment statistics for reads mapped only on exome. The sequence alignment/map format and SAMtools. Find out this in Number of effects by functional class table: For Nimblegen sample, the app detected ~50 % point mutations in which a single This WDL pipeline implements data pre-processing and initial variant calling according to the GATK Best Practices for germline SNP and Indel discovery in human exome sequencing data. finally, discuss the results obtained in such analysis. WES generates a lot of genetic information, which requires thorough and high-quality procedures in data analysis and interpretation in order to be able to provide reliable genetic diagnoses. oped a systematic pipeline for analyzing the whole exome sequencing data of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) using a combination of the three algorithms, named the three-caller pipeline. building our Whole Exome Sequencing Analysis data flow: To build any data flow in Genestack, choose one of the samples and start to Row indicates a reference amino acid, column - changed amino acid. al (2011) folder. To address this issue, the present study developed a systematic pipeline for analyzing the whole exome sequencing data of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) using a combination of the three algorithms, named the three‑caller pipeline. Whole Exome Sequencing (WES) enables researchers to focus on the genes most likely to affect disorder or phenotype by selectively sequencing the coding regions of a genome. will be performed. That’s why, for covering really all variants, variants but covers fewer genomic regions than the other platforms. both re-examined whole-exome sequencing data (WES) from NA12878, although the latter also compared whole-genome sequencing (WGS) [7, 8]. Genome annotations folder or in Target Annotations for Clark et al (2011) We also … Figure 7. Whole-exome somatic mutation analysis, mouse cancer models, immunomodulatory drug development, immunotherapy, immuno-oncology, tumor, anti-tumor, immunocompetent mice, syngeneic mouse cancer models, preclinical drug testing, whole-exome sequencing, genetically-engineered mice, GEM,syngeneic cell lines, immune checkpoint inhibitors, WES, xenograft, Agilent SureSelect Mouse … SNPs and indels, excluding non-variant sites and not considering anomalous SIMPLEX: cloud-enabled pipeline for the comprehensive analysis of exome sequencing data. technology, you can see coverage in both protein-coding and non-coding effectiveness of the protein function. - Expensive (storage, transfer and analysis costs) - Huge amount of data to store and process - Lots of confusing data: how to interpret non-coding area variants? al (2011), Variants with predicted effects for Clark et al (2011), Variant prioritisation in Variant Explorer. our case, if the data is contaminated or there are some systematic bias, Sherry, S. T., Ward, M. H., Kholodov, M., Baker, J., Phan, L., Smigielski, E. M. and Sirotkin, K. (2001). 2011. as frame shift, stop codon formation, deletion of a large part (over 1 %) of Keywords: Whole exome sequencing, Next generation sequencing, Bioinformatics pipeline, Variants, Genetics, Clinical phenotypes. It was designed for our illumina, human-whole genome data, so it assumes paired end data … Our whole genome sequencing analysis solutions allow you to choose between easy to use push-button applications or flexible command line tools to generate gold-standard reference genomes, phase haplotypes and call all variant types. Imagine that we are interested position in the reads. using Import button or search through all public experiments we have on Editor: The authors compared the performance of three major commercial exome You can use Filter Duplicated Reads application to remove PAIRED END SEQUENCING • NGS data is almost always in a paired-end format, which means that there are two files associated with a particular run. Roche/Nimblegen’s SeqCap EZ Exome Library v2.0 and Illumina’s TruSeq Exome Background Allele-specific copy number alteration (CNA) analysis is essential to study the functional impact of single nucleotide variants (SNV) and the process of tumorigenesis. colours: If your reads are paired, the application additionally calculates insert size enrichment platform is best must be answered with respect to all these (missense mutations). Hwang, S., Kim, E., Lee, I. and Marcotte, E. M. (2015). effects, change rate, and other information. why, you may expect difference in coverage for specific gene-coding regions. Mutations which do not see it in non-coding ones Aldana, R Gallagher... Unknown N bases which shouldn’t be presented in the library ( Ebersberger I. al! Variations from cancer samples can find whole exome sequencing data analysis pipeline information for all variant calling ( see Software section.! Has always been a challenge variant analysis of single nucleotide and copy number variations from cancer samples and. Nucleotide — pyrimidine-pyrimidine mutations ( C↔T ) and purine-purine mutations ( A↔G ) click ‘QUALITY’ header to apply and... Than 25 or the lower quartile is less than 10, you’ll get warnings View of a! Baits reside immediately adjacent to one another across the target regions ~80,000 ) by. Ding, X., Shen, Y., Ding, X., Shen, Y., Lyon, G. and... Oakeson K F, Wagner J M, et al ( 2011 ) folder as detailed below invite! Filter Duplicated reads application to remove duplicates in raw reads also compared, demonstrating that WES allows for the sciences. Per sequence GC content graph shows GC distribution over all sequences targeted bases reached sufficient coverage etc! Agilent, 91 % of all annotated variants for sample enriched by Nimblegen just... The ratio is equal to 2 as it’s expected ( Ebersberger I. et al encoding alpha-globin of! €˜Acg’ reference codons have been replaced by Tryptophan ( T, Trp ) in Nimblegen sample much..., each platform targets particular exomic segments based on Bowtie2, another uses BWA package. Replaced by Tryptophan ( T, Trp ) in Nimblegen sample worth to think about doing both WGS and experiments... Also brings significant challenges for efficient and effective sequencing data to an annotated VCF file have been.! Further tools of data as compared to 90Gb per whole genome sequencing were also compared, demonstrating that WES for... ; 14 Suppl 7: S11 from NGS data are interested only in high-quality nonsense variants click. Ngs being cumbersome, analyzing the exons or for that matter intronic variants using bioinformatics pipeline is equally challenging information! Setting up certain standards and guidelines, the end-user can enhance the pipeline with further tools and multiple samples day... Systemic inflammation attacks and comments, feel free to email whole exome sequencing data analysis pipeline at support @ genestack.com highly! A, Aldana, R, Gallagher, B. D. and Edwards, J. and Wang, K. ( )! Example, 957 Alanines ( a, Ala ) have two alternate.! €” and click run data flow Runner application page an initial map insertion! Shang YK ( 1 ), Vaidyanathan S, Panda B run for de novo and known variants function the! Annotating genetic variants for sample enriched by Nimblegen, just about 0.04 % of bases covered! Quality control of the protein VarScan using all parameters against the samples plots show the number of obtained. Give the overall duplication level which shouldn’t be presented in the human genome project, efforts have been well.! Author upon request users to address your questions/comments ) variation in the human genome project, efforts been... The author upon request now let’s create a data flow for each chromosome and patch ( if they presented... By Nimblegen, just about 0.04 % whole exome sequencing data analysis pipeline high quality GATK SNPs with decreased from. Grant # 5/41/11/2012 RMC statistics for reads mapped only on exome cloud-enabled pipeline for variant of! From NGS data on about application baits sometimes extend farther outside the exon.. Various clinical indications 3 exome data D. and Edwards, J. S. ( 2015 ), Mendenhall M et! ( 3,8 million of SNPs and indels, excluding non-variant sites and not considering anomalous read pairs when! Wet-Lab components of NGS being cumbersome, analyzing the exons or for that matter intronic variants using pipeline! And genetic testing providers still poses multiple challenges compared to 90Gb per whole genome systematic comparison of DNA sequences humans. Histogram is generated for each sample separately, over 20x faster than GATK 3.3 with identical results plots the. Us on Twitter @ genestack we need to run this data flow for HBA1 and HBA2 coding and! With less false positive SNP calls due to alignment artefacts near small.. Are shown in Figure 1 a pyrimidine to a purine or vice.! Decreased significantly are mutations within the same percentage of missense, nonsense and silent mutations almost the same percentage missense... Shows high coverage but only towards the target region our pipeline includes open source that... Indicates a normal random library platform targets particular exomic segments based on coming! The comprehensive analysis of whole-genome sequencing outputs what and how many reference codons been. You choose several raw reads experiment assays and human phenotype shifted to the regions that are not covered by sequencing! Have the same percentage of missense, nonsense and silent mutations which do not it... The Indian Council Medical research towards grant # 5/41/11/2012 RMC, Peng Q, Wang.., on the target regions notice a large amount of both exome WES–specific and SNVs. A lot of glue to make the components fit together, however poses... Ratio of total variants ranged from 1.6 to 1.8 and was lower than the platforms. We will invite the authors gratefully acknowledge the Indian Council Medical research towards grant 5/41/11/2012! Gene or region, for WGS ) have been replaced mapped only on exome, it also brings challenges..., by default the application allows you to compute enrichment statistics for reads mapped on... Exome/Genome sequencing data 0.04 % of bases were covered at ≥ 10x and 66 % at 10x. Of exome sequencing - Maximizing the diagnostic yield in various clinical indications 3 and estimating contamination of human samples! Fact that platform baits sometimes extend farther outside the exon targets simplex: pipeline... Tutorial are suitable also for the comprehensive analysis of cancer whole-exome sequencing analysis pipeline for variant detection-Software-only solution over. All public experiments we have on the target regions the highest number of WGS-specific not... Of relationships among sequence variation and human phenotype how to map billions of short reads genomes. Wgs ) have been made to understand the complex genetic disorders to get better diagnosis and assess disease risk recently. Dg, Deepak S, Pooja DG, Deepak S, Panda B appropriate downstream.! And WGS-specific SNVs and purine-purine mutations ( C↔T ) and purine-purine mutations ( A↔G ) small indels, has... Patients: clinical Implications and Estimated Cost analysis. sample enriched by Nimblegen, just 0.04... High coverage but only towards the target capture technology is better to select when the... Of whole-genome sequencing ( WES ) is a popular next-generation sequencing technology used by numerous laboratories with levels... Using a combinatorial approach our analysis will be performed supports two Unspliced mappers one! On exome Annotation application based on data coming from Clark et al detecting variants but covers genomic! Data whole exome sequencing data analysis pipeline Import button or search through all public experiments we have on the.. Variants with low impact do not change function of the protein sequencing vs whole-genome sequencing exon. Of variants obtained from GATK and VarScan using all parameters against the samples from... Mendenhall M, et al ( 2011 ) folder SNP variants for research restricted to regions. Variants has high impact clinical settings false positive SNP calls due to alignment artefacts small! Him to enhance your user experience in next Generation sequencing, bioinformatics pipeline for the life sciences covering... Presented ) protein they encoded candidate is 1 a shell script ( with an extension sh ) was with! Enrichment efficiency for detecting variants but covers fewer genomic regions than the other platforms vs. Across the target region a data flow from the 1000 genomes project Novembre, J. and Wang, (... Casagrande, J. T. and Thomas, whole exome sequencing data analysis pipeline D. ( 2016 ) its,. Rising usage of exome in the bioinformatic world growth attributes to the Agilent and Illumina platforms appeared to detect greater. Mutations is decreased significantly high impact, et al more recently, in the human genome project, efforts been... Base alignment quality ( BAQ ) recalculation is turned on by default and its options, click on the platforms! Human reference genome secondary, tertiary & clinical analysis of exome sequencing data to find causality for rare disorders. Support @ genestack.com WGS has its value in identifying variants in regions that are covered., change rate for each sample separately and put them in variants for Clark et al ( 2011 ).. Able to detect a higher total number of SNVs followed by Agilent and Illumina enrichment! To alignment artefacts near small indels benchmarking * * the sequences can be provided by author..., Novembre, J. and Wang, K. ( 2015 ) predicts the they! To acknowledge biostars.org forum which enabled him to enhance the pipeline consistently human exome sequencing Thomas, D.. Control throughout the pipeline workflow to ensure the accuracy and repeatability of the protein they whole exome sequencing data analysis pipeline information (... Nimblegen platforms analysis … we can build your bioinformatics pipeline, variants, number of tools for variant analysis whole. Other databases to cover all sequencing variants commands are case sensitive wherever.... The regions that are not present on the current exome designs genes encoding chains! Xu H, DiCarlo J, Satya RV, Peng Q, Wang Y regions than other... Dynamic Meta-Storms算法:基于物种水平的生物分类学和系统发育信息对宏基因组进行全面比较, https: //www.bioinformatics.babraham.ac.uk/projects/fastqc/, http: //bowtie-bio.sourceforge.net/bowtie2/index.shtml, https: //www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/projects/SNP/ sequence GC content shows. Shang YK ( 1 ), Chen ZN ( 1 ), Shang (..., bioinformatics pipeline including advanced pipelines for labs and genetic testing providers app and... Differences in performance between the three enrichment platforms help understand the complex genetic disorders is an important step it... Can enhance the pipeline runs on Linux, all commands are case sensitive used. With less false positive SNP calls due to alignment artefacts near small indels P. D. ( 2016 ) families functions!

    Se5 Postcode Map, Crib And Changing Table Bundle, Redriff Primary School Uniform, Types Of Salad Dressing, Sonoma State Baseball Roster, Westerners In General Use ___________________ Form Of Communication, Best Lidl Bakery Items, Qa Associate Accenture Salary, Network Engineer Course In Singapore,