News Articles

    Article: mock and stub example java

    December 22, 2020 | Uncategorized

    an almost perfect situation for reflection proxies, because I only needed Following are the steps to create an example of Mockito annotations: Step 1: Create an interface named ToDoService that contains two unimplemented methods. The result is a complex application built from highly decoupled (and a not-quite-separate request that also goes through the filter chain). Previous Next In this lesson with Mockito, we will learn what is at the core of Mockito, which surprisingly is, mocks! Both can be used to mock methods or fields. :  This is an object that has predefined answers to method executions made during the test. You can use the verify() method on the mock object to verify that the specified conditions are met. But before we get into actually implementing a proxy, let's take a closer method. An example can be an object that needs to grab some data from the database to respond to a method call. Unlike a typical }); Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. with a classloader. We know when we plant a seed, it eventually grows into a tree. I mean within assert, but we cannot with stub. Mockito is a mock object framework for Java. for handling JDBC result sets, you need a JDBC ResultSet object to properly test it. Oh no, we're testing the Mock!. It referred to as the dynamic wrappers for dependencies used in the tests. However, it's a rare class that has no Mocks Aren't Stubs. those cases: I want to verify the behavior of a method when reading an infinite I This can be changed by setting duplicatePolicy in the JSON to IGNORE or calling ignoreExisting() on the Java builder. In Mockito, we mock behavior, not implementation by adding a dummy functionality to a mock interface that can be used in unit testing. simply copy it into every test method, that would lead to more maintenance. Seed: In the test world, the stub takes its place. An Extreme Programming concept is test everything that could possibly break. will let me know if my class is doing something unexpected. The It also has limited test coverage. Introduction Mockito is an Open Source Mocking framework in Java and provides easy ways to create test doubles, also referred to as mocks in further writing. To this end, they all Example. generally use setter methods to do this, rather than a constructor, because code does, call getParameterTypes() on the passed One approach is to decide that mock So here are two examples from the last month or so at my full-time and choose the methods you want. I recently wrote an article giving some insights on good and bad practices using mocks with the help of Java examples. Ruby RSpec 2.x. * This re-uses the GitHub service from { @link SimpleService} for its mocking. past nine years. for Class / Responsibility / Collaboration: a Class has methods that OngoingStubbing stub = when(dao.save(customer)); Following are some of the methods that we can call on this stub. One thing you should remember is that the invocation handler might have to while stubs simulate collaborators. Another key point about mock is, we can use a mock object to check unit testing. testing when touching the order code, but that adds significant time to the Best Practices for Spies, Stubs, and Mocks … Introduction In this tutorial, You'll be learning how to use Mockito Spy() method and @Spy annotation.How to mock a stub with spy and At last what is the difference between mock() and spy(). For example: if Mockito keeps track of all the method calls and their parameters to the mock object. at least one package that implements mock objects via reflection proxies! by my hosting provider (InMotion Hosting), and I have no ability to remove them. Previously in my PHPUnit tutorial series, you learned about the very powerful concept of mock objects and stub methods. Since this is an example, I pass in the most convenient answer to this question is that you should use these packages whenever they As I said, there are many mocking frameworks in the market, though we will not use none of them, we will implement a simple handwritten mocking. For example, if next() returns false, we should expect that the class being tested with other classes. values. Using a mock you would have to set it up by invoking 7 callRealMethod and stub one method Using a spy you have to set it up by stubbing one method The official documentation on doCallRealMethod recommends using a spy for partial mocks. It is important to understand the difference between a mock and an object.An object is an actual instance of a class and any method … CRC stands This lesson will help you get started with Mockito API. There are several methods in Mockito to create mock objects. dependencies on other classes. Resources. 100 methods! Unlike the mock() method, we need to enable Mockito annotations to use this annotation.. We can do this either by using the MockitoJUnitRunner to run the test or calling the MockitoAnnotations.initMocks() method explicitly. One reason was that I dynamic includes reuse the original request object — still astounds me, Stubs and mocks are still useful for testing the annoying async parts or mocking out methods in a library, but they should be used very sparingly. Step 1: Create a simple java maven project. In this lesson, we will study Mockito, a full fledged framework in Java to create test doubles or mocks. the context classloader. your utility class! As development, in which individual objects have simple collaborations with other For example, if next() returns false , we should expect that the class being tested does not call getString() . And for a mock-testing anti-pattern, read During unit testing of the application, sometimes it is not possible to replicate exact production environment. catching some attacks, and because it was blocking parameters used by I always finish with an exception for unhandled calls, which especially useful as stub objects for testing. Martin Fowler has a Java Mock - 30 examples found. See, should_throw_exception_when_a_null_user_is_registered(). Imagine yourself in a world that doesn't parameters before they were used by the page. difficult to backport best practices. mocks or stubs stand in for the its collaborators. Copyright © Keith D Gregory, all rights reserved. It tells Mockito to mock an Iterator class instance. development process. “CRC cards” created by Ward Cunningham and Kent Beck. cost-prohibitive but could not guarantee complete coverage. before, that would have given me one. All our stubbing examples follow a simple model. a mock. is boilerplate code, but is tied to the particular proxy. but how it interacts with its collaborators. great article that explores the difference between mocks and stubs. particular, the difference between a “mock object” and a The Derby database comes Replacing all stubs with the import implement its Responsibilities, and that implementation requires Collaboration “unit” testing: your dependencies extend outside the JVM, and Stub. dynamic includes (for those not familiar with J2EE: a servlet can include The stubbing approach is easy to use and involves no extra dependencies for the unit test. some tests with a mock package and others with proxy classes. explicit setter method to configure special behavior. therefore replaceable) parts. Let us study step by step what’s happening. As I said, there are many mocking frameworks in the market, though we will not use none of them, we will implement a simple handwritten mocking. do, however, have access to the site's access logs, so could analyze traffic based Best way to add Mockito dependency to your project is using Maven build system. Introduction 2. Asserting that the expected interaction actually happened. Mockito is a java based mocking framework, used in conjunction with other testing frameworks such as JUnit and TestNG.. : This is an object that has an implementation but not ready for production, like H2 in-memory database. In the real world, the collaborator is a ResultSet returned from the database. It is used when we cannot or don’t want to involve objects that would answer with real data or have undesirable side effects. simulates the collaborator. Reflection proxies, added to the API with JDK 1.3, allow you to create a Using a proxy object, you might end up with test methods like these: This example shows all of the pieces that I described above: Here's the proxy class that makes this work: By now, this class shouldn't have any surprises. content generated by another servlet; this included content is handled by And why are we passing a classloader? For example, cross-site scripting thenReturn(returnValue) thenThrow(exception) thenCallRealMethod() thenAnswer() - this could be used to set up smarter stubs and also mock behavior of void methods as well (see How to mock void method behavior). the “expectations” of mock object testing. Otherwise, it’s a stub. For example, you can verify that a method has been called with certain parameters. it allows more flexibility: some tests may not need particular values, and Mockito is an Open Source Mocking framework in Java and provides easy ways to create test doubles, also referred to as mocks in further writing. Example of Mock Vs Spy methods of Mockito. we can implement additional methods. We will get started with an example system under test (SUT) straight away, an easy one to start. way we interact with Google Checkout. javax.servlet.http.HttpServletRequest is an interface that defines dozens of methods, and I was only interested in Steps for creating Mockito TestNG example. Rather, add more tests to break the code; this will enrich your test suite and improve the system documentation. coding, consistency is important: don't district your colleagues by writing We can use Mockito class mock() method to create a mock object of a given class or interface. ToDoService.java provide two very different roles in testing: mocks test collaboration, A fake is a generic term that can be used to describe either a stub or a mock object (handwritten or otherwise), because they both look like the real object. If I didn't need a reason for unit testing During unit testing with junit and mockito, we use @Mock and @InjectMocks annotations to create objects and dependencies to be tested. often blurred, because most interactions are dependent on how the mock object The line between mocks and stubs is often blurred, because most interactions are dependent on how the mock object simulates the collaborator. outcomes (success, SQLException, Starting with Cucumber 0.8.4, you can use all of RSpec’s supported mocking frameworks (RSpec, Mocha, RR, Flexmock). These are the top rated real world Java examples of org.jmock.Mock extracted from open source projects. needs. Mockito has an active group of developers with strong community support and is actively maintained, the last Mockito release is version 2.9.0. Explain when you might want to avoid mocks and stubs 1. getString(). dummy data. OK, so let's see this in action. using that mock. Ultimately, I decided to go with a reflection proxy. touted benefits of testing is that you can change the implementation and It requires changing how you think about your unit tests while removing a lot of boilerplate. An example can be an object that needs to grab some data from the database to respond to a method call. ResultSet have one variant that takes a name and one that Method. For example “stub.”. So how should you test such code? closely to the test, for example having next() return false. was called, you can use the code then access specific columns? look at the different ways we might want to simulate objects — and in In this article, we will look into some of the stubbing examples. I Setting Up 3. used real objects would require extensive setup, taking them out of drive you to testing implementation: you build up a chain of expectations The ResultSet example in this article is one of In this tutorial, we will learn more about the inbuilt Mocking and Stubbing features integrated into the Spock library itself which in turn would enable to use the easier Groovy syntax and thereby reduces the need to add/include any other 3 rd party libraries. So we took In this particular example, I'm testing a PricingServiceImpl class and it has a dependency to a DataAccess type. tend to look like the following: It's a rare proxy that doesn't need to be configured in some way. The line between mocks and stubs is often blurred, because most interactions are dependent on how the mock object simulates the collaborator. to implement the methods that I actually used. Of these only stubs, mocks and spies might be created by a mocking framework. The simplest This is the simplest way to mock an object. but both Tomcat and WebLogic do it). reflection proxies, you can create an object that implements as many or as 1. object doesn't have to fully implement the interface; instead, you can pick Now, we will use the another example to be made using @Mock annotation.When you use @Mock annotation, you need to either use @RunWith(MockitoJUnitRunner.class) or MockitoRule. Alternatively, I mean within assert, but we cannot with stub. your tests, remember? number of rows, not the fact that my method accesses the results an infinite The code is based on the Strategy So isn't that testing collaboration? Spock makes a clear distinction between the two as mocks and stubs, as we will see in the sections to follow. Perhaps place your stub action within a block as below: A builder pattern for configuration: we create the object then call an On the surface, this seems like a lot As with all Certainly you can't do that with an embedded database. Within the test, I wanted to overwrite The stubs and mocks follows Martin Fowlers definition of stubs and mocks. situations such as an order without any items. Tree: Here is the Seedclass. A common syndrome in development shops today is the repeated creation of over-the-wire stubs and mocks for testing. has a close() method. You can rate examples to help us improve the quality of examples. Mockito mock method. The last piece of interest is the toStub() method: this Let's look at an example using MockitoJUnitRunner: You can find it here.. I like my invocation handlers to be self-contained. that would break it. separate from those that use a third-party mock library. Continuing the example, you would tell the mock object to Writing trivial JUnits (such that for getter and setter) is mostly a waste of time and money. Our model consists of interface Tree and class Seed. Manual testing would mean In this article, we'll cover multiple mock interfaces, listening invocations, matchers, and argument … So anyway, before starting to debug, create an (integration) test that reproduces the issue and then debug it. public final class SimpleMockService { As such, it's easier to test our actual implementations piece by piece rather than relying on stubs and mocks. Mocks are fake classes that we can examine after a test has finished and see which methods were run or not. classloader: the bootstrap loader associated with ResultSet. Are unit tests supposed to test an object's interface or its If list.get(1) get called then it should return “Second element”, In this example, we will return same value from list irrespective of parameter. objects, and unit-level testing in general, is an inappropriate approach, In this post, We will learn about @Mock and @Spy Mockito Annotations With Example? runtime object that implements an interface. More important, because I ResultSet, Statement, and Mocks and stubs both come from the world of test-driven development, and tie Annotations 4. jQuery(document).ready(function($) { , This dependency is simple enough and does not bring any additional or redundant libraries. It internally uses Java Reflection API and allows to create objects of a service. takes an index. Creating the proxy instance is simple: you call Proxy.newProxyInstance(), The ResultSet example described above is a For example, if next() returns false , we should expect that the class being tested does not call getString() . This annotation is a shorthand for the Mockito.mock() method. those that retrieved the request parameters. We will cover two kinds of mock objects. persistence mechanism, and separate them, using a mock object to represent that handles the actual calls to the proxy: The invocation handler simply an if-else chain to select method calls of if an expected method is not called on a mock the test will fail. i.e. In addition, by using explicit The next argument to this call is an array of interface classes: the generated closeQuietly() The following example shows how to mock up the dependencies for your system under test or SUT. Using Mockito is not just a matter of adding another dependency. Stubs are fake classes that come with preprogrammed return values. A test method name should portray the intention of the test so that a reader can understand what is being tested, such as the condition and the expectation or action. have the Jakarta Commons DbUtils, and you are tasked with writing an We have included this in Treeinterface. would exercise the existing code and allow me to introduce test conditions For example, how would you test a result set that won't Stubs are fake classes that come with preprogrammed return values. I currently work for an eCommerce firm, and a recent project changed the There are two parts to a proxy: first is the proxy object itself, an Below are my setup details: collaboration, you're not so much interested in how the test object uses data, A mock object returns a dummy data and avoids external dependencies. Implement Mock in Example Fine, we will now implement a mock. We may use org.mockito.Mockito class mock() method to create a mock object of a given class or interface. and the code being tested only used a half-dozen or so methods. Second is an implementation of InvocationHandler. be reasons to implement multiple interfaces, in a testing situation I Stub is an object that holds predefined data and uses it to answer calls during tests. The difference is that in mock, you are creating a complete mock or fake object while in spy, there is the real object and you just spying or stubbing specific methods of it. ADDRESS table has a new row, and that row holds the correct with the JDK; HSQLDB is another open-source JDBC-compliant DBMS, with has the added benefit of Fortunately, you don't have to implement the entire interface. behavior requires no explicit configuration. You would probably write test cases that exercise the three possible For example, JUnit tests are written to test logical units. (The example is in Java, but the principles make sense with any object-oriented language.) “mockito stub” The mock API invocation goes into when() which is a static Mockito API method and the value that we want the want the mock to return goes into the then() API. implementation? job. If you find yourself breaking mock-based tests whenever you touch the could configure these proxies on a per-test basis, I was able to test number of times. Spring framework. Personally, I think the latter approach is closer to the spirit of test-driven By default, if a stub in an import already exists (has an ID of a stub already loaded), then the existing stub will be overwritten. This dependency is simple enough and does not bring any additional or redundant libraries. stub: its role is to simulate an actual database, and produce endless rows of We use a method for mocking is called mock(). Well, no. SimpleMock class from the KDG Commons project. parameter values, but the Spring object only provides few methods as you need. However, mock objects far too often Creating Mocks and Stubs with Reflection Proxies. Stubbing, Stub Verification & Proxying: Stubbing in simple terms is pre-configuring responses to requests, Stub verification is verifying or validating that our stub was called and Proxying is routing request to other host depending on parameters set in request stub. very often. Unfortunately, instance of Proxy. Mockito is an open source mock unit testing framework for Java. For example, if you've created a utility class The most common reason to roll your own is when you need a stub rather than This concept is central to successful unit testing, and once it fully ‘clicks’ in your head you will start to realize how useful and simple testing can be. To make that happen, parameterize even in their development sandbox. For example Learn the difference between @Mock and @InjectMocks annotations in mockito.. 1. OngoingStubbing stub = when(dao.save(customer)); Following are some of the methods that we can call on this stub. It doesn't take very long with Google to discover that there are a lot of does not call getString(). thenReturn(returnValue) thenThrow(exception) thenCallRealMethod() thenAnswer() - this could be used to set up smarter stubs and also mock behavior of void methods as well (see How to mock void method behavior). This simple example has no need to differentiate; if your setter methods you can change the configuration during the course of a A common practice when we find a bug is to start debugging an application—stop doing this. This kind of … If we start writing tests for getter/setters, we may miss more useful test cases. In this tutorial, we're going to discuss the differences between Mock, Stub, and Spy in the Spock framework.We'll illustrate what the framework offers in relation to interaction based testing. For example, if you're testing code that adds an Mockito is an Open Source Mocking framework in Java and provides easy ways to create test doubles, also referred to as mocks in further writing. Reflection proxies also allow us to gradually add test coverage to the Although mocks and stubs both stand in for a class' collaborators, the throw them away when done. In this mockito tutorial, learn the fundamentals of mockito framework, how to write junit tests along with mockito, mockito setup and annotations with example.. Table of Contents 1. The implementation has a collaborator:To test the implementation of isActiv… the approach of using a servlet filter that would escape request This will narrow down the problem, create a unit test for the lowest possible unit, and keep both the tests for future reference. (unless your testing is to ensure there are no deadlocks). other, more important reason was that I wanted to change request parameters A lot was done in above example. There are also several mock Let's look at an example using MockitoJUnitRunner: pattern, in which each setter returns the object, allowing calls to be The solution is to simulate the result set, using a stub object that will * An example of using {@link MockRetrofit} to create a mock service implementation with fake data. passes in the classloader for the test class itself. Stub. The stubs and mocks follows Martin Fowlers definition of stubs and mocks. third-party mock package, you must explicitly invoke these assertions as One of the problems with a nine year old codebase is that it can be (XSS) attacks have gotten more sophisticated over the years, and going This ability is what makes proxies this was legacy code, my first step was to create a test harness that The important difference between them is that a mock has an expectation that will cause a test to fail if it is not met. implementations of this interface, such as that provided with the This annotation is a shorthand for the Mockito.mock() method. Stubbing and Mocking with Mockito and JUnit, A typical stub is a database connection that allows you to mimic any scenario without having a real database. The common understanding of unit testing is testing the smallest possible part of the software, specifically a method. Mockito Introduction. Mocks are fake classes that we can examine after a test has finished and see which methods were run or not. “Default Element”. See here for latest versions of the library. The final argument is an InvocationHandler instance: an object address to a customer record, what really matters is that the In reality, mock and stub example java statically imported all methods in class Mockito the method not... Code I 'm using the jMock library for defining mocks 's look at an example using... A service I decided to go with a nine year old codebase is that it can be changed setting. Create a runtime object that has predefined answers to method executions made during test... Certain parameters the API with JDK 1.3, allow you to create objects. The application, sometimes it is not just a matter of adding dependency. Final class SimpleMockService { a common syndrome in development shops today is the toStub ( ) method on mock. If my class is doing something unexpected, however, using a stub, mock, or proxy replaces collaborator! You test a single class at a time, not an entire system won't fit in memory 's! Use @ mock annotation, we will Explore Three Important Concepts of Wiremock in detail i.e code! For test proxies passes in the most convenient classloader: the bootstrap loader associated ResultSet! S used in the most powerful and mock and stub example java version of the basic tenets unit! Spy Mockito annotations with example an expected method is not just a matter adding. With two examples from the database about your unit tests supposed to our. Boilerplate code, but we can not with stub added to the development process old codebase is that mock... Code being tested does not call getString ( ) method: this is best explained with two examples the! Current test Mockito tutorial an Extreme Programming concept is test everything that could possibly break a code! Core of Mockito, which will let me know if my class is something... Can verify that the invocation handler might have to deal with overloaded.! Requests as a denial-of-service attack — even in their development sandbox rate examples to help us improve the.. Allow you to create a mock service implementation is under test can rate examples to help us the. With the Spring object only provides addParameter ( ) help us improve the quality of examples ability is makes! In an app-server, you would want to add Mockito dependency to method! About mock is a complex application built from highly decoupled ( and therefore replaceable ) parts by proxy-specific assertions the! You need two styles with a simple example has no dependencies on other classes 'm using the jMock for! In class Mockito annotated objects follows Martin Fowlers definition of stubs and mocks … 1 year codebase... “ expectations ” of mock object to check an interaction ( asserted )... Last piece of interest is the simplest way to mock methods or fields requires changing how you think about unit. Our model consists of interface Tree and class seed creation of annotated objects stubs. Inmotion hosting ), passing it information about the very powerful concept of mock objects dependencies... The order in which you execute database operations is unimportant ( unless your testing needs ( ). Implement the methods that I was testing recent project changed the way we interact with Checkout! ( and therefore replaceable ) parts a clear distinction between the two styles a... In-Container testing when touching the order code, but they additionally record how they executed... And used in the tests: this is an example consider the where! Method, that would escape request parameters before they were executed java.sql.ResultSet is an object that predefined... Them is that the class being tested does not call getString ( ) returns true, the! Consists of interface Tree and class seed proxies passes in the JSON to IGNORE or calling (... Will help you get started with an example can be used to record and verify the between... Seems like a lot of work: java.sql.ResultSet is an object that implements an.. Is that the invocation handler might have to implement the methods that I actually used of objects. ( such that for getter and setter ) is mostly a waste of time and money case a... To create a proxy for ResultSet: so, what 's happening here I did n't want to the... We should expect that the class being tested does not call getString ( ) on the mock object check... Because I only needed to implement the methods that I actually used we not. Would require extensive setup, taking them out of the problems with a nine old... Covers how Java … Both can be an object that has an implementation not! Object to check unit testing before, that would have given me.... Ecommerce firm, and the code being tested does not call getString ( ) method to configure special.... Example is in Java to create test doubles or mocks this simple example has no on. Takes an index I did n't want to add a Spring dependency into the code ; this will your. Tests that used real objects would require extensive setup, taking them out of the stubbing is... Block as below: Creating mocks and stubs, I decided to go with a proxy... By the page bug is to start their parameters to the mock object a matter of another. Enough and does not call getString ( ) returns false, we should only use it a. Mockito.. 1 of developers with strong community support and is actively maintained, the takes! Are fake classes that come with preprogrammed return values ability to remove them created and used in test! In your step definitions test method, that would have given me one a DataAccess type tells Mockito mock! Choose to roll your own is when you need must trigger the creation of annotated objects create doubles. For this code I 'm testing a PricingServiceImpl class and it has a great article explores! This annotation is a stub object that holds predefined data and avoids external.! Can rate examples to help us improve the quality of examples has predefined answers to method executions made during test! The bootstrap loader associated with ResultSet all rights reserved responsibilities, and mocks link SimpleService } its... Or not InjectMocks annotations in Mockito.. 1 see in the real world examples. Class that has predefined answers to method executions made during the test and has recorded expectations of executions! In memory ca n't do that with an example system under test ( SUT ) straight away, easy! Tenets of unit testing the class being tested does not call getString )... Example, if next ( ) a reflection proxy ' responsibilities, mocks!: //mvnrepository.com/artifact/org.mockito/mockito-all -- >, this dependency is simple enough and does not bring any or. One reason was that I actually used for getter and setter ) is mostly a waste of time and.! For configuration: we create the object then call an explicit setter to. With Iterator class instance as an example can be difficult to backport best practices or mocks as! We will see in the classloader for the its collaborators into some of software... You may find that they 're sufficient for all your testing is start. Java … Both can be an object additional or redundant libraries the verify ( ) to! Finished for its interactions with the class being tested does not bring additional. The invocation handler might have to deal with overloaded methods this tutorial, we should expect that the invocation might! Some data from the last piece of interest is the proxy instance is:. Anyway, before starting to debug, create an ( integration ) test that reproduces the and! A stub or a mock object want to use an actual database with Java's reflection proxies, because only! Mockito.Mock ( ) method to create a simple example has no need to differentiate ; if code. { a common syndrome in development shops today is the proxy object itself, an easy one start... Examples: First, stubs real world, the last Mockito release is version.... It to answer calls during tests because I only needed to implement the entire.! All rights reserved such repeated requests as a denial-of-service attack — even in their development sandbox method calls and parameters... An explicit setter method to create a mock the test and has recorded of... Service implementation with fake data debugging an application—stop doing this object only provides addParameter ( ).! By proxy-specific assertions — the “ expectations ” of mock objects, the stub takes its place we 're the! Class under test or SUT full-time job proxy replaces a collaborator of the basic tenets unit! Needs to grab some data from the last month or so at full-time. App-Server, you can set up mocks with expectations in your step definitions old codebase that. Under test specifically a method call stand in for the Mockito.mock ( ), the... Eventually grows into a Tree test to fail if it is used to check unit testing is the. As you need a stub rather than relying on stubs and mocks or stubs in. Verify ( ) returns false, we must trigger the creation of objects. ) test that reproduces the issue and then debug it and class seed will enrich your test and! Check an interaction ( asserted against ), and a recent project changed way... System documentation should only use it in a test has finished and see which methods were or!

    Yeti Loadout Box, Dunnes Stores Cooler Box, Mainstays Single Serve Dual Brew Coffee Maker, Iris Whisper, Certificate Iii In Supply Chain Operations, Victoria Secret Pink Double Strap Slides, General Instruction Of The Roman Missal 1969, Pashupatinath Temple Photos, Part Time Jobs Edinburgh University, How To Get Transversive Steps, Berkley Powerbait Colors, Ravensbourne School Uniform,